Liability depends on why the kill switch failed. The manufacturer can be responsible if the tool was defectively built, designed, or labeled. A store or distributor that only sold the tool is protected unless it had substantial control over the failed part, altered the tool in a way that helped cause the injury, or knew or should have known about the defect. A repair shop or rental company may be liable for careless maintenance. If you were hurt at work, you usually cannot sue your employer, but you can collect workers’ compensation and still sue these companies. Our North Mississippi product liability attorneys trace the failure to its source.
Who Can Be Liable if a Kill Switch Fails?
Who is responsible depends on the facts, and more than one party can share the blame. Depending on why the switch failed, responsibility may fall on:
- The manufacturer, if the switch was defective when the tool left its control
- A distributor or store, but only in the limited situations described below
- A repair shop, rental company, or other company that owned or maintained the tool, if its careless work caused the failure
Your employer is usually not on this list. Mississippi’s workers’ compensation law generally bars a lawsuit against a covered employer, as explained below.
Mississippi protects sellers that only pass a product along. A store or distributor that sold the tool is responsible only if it:
- Had substantial control over the design, testing, manufacture, packaging, or labeling of the part that failed
- Altered or modified the tool, and that change was a substantial factor in causing your injury
- Knew or should have known about the defect when it sold the tool
A store that sold a sealed box and had no reason to know of the defect is protected.
A repair can also change who is responsible. A repair shop, rental company, or other company that did a careless repair or failed to maintain the tool can face a negligence claim, but you must prove its conduct caused your injury. The Mississippi Supreme Court ended a driver’s negligent-repair claim against a car dealership because no evidence connected the repairs to the crash. After the crash, a body shop replaced the steering parts, and they were destroyed or recycled before either side could inspect them.
What Makes a Power Tool Defective?
A kill switch or emergency shutoff stops a power tool when you release the trigger or press the off button. Federal workplace safety rules require employers in general industry to make sure hand-held circular saws with blades larger than 2 inches, and chain saws used at work, have a switch that will shut off the power when the pressure is released.
Drills, belt sanders, reciprocating saws, and grinders with wheels larger than 2 inches need the same kind of switch. On those tools, a lock-on button is allowed only if the same finger that turns the tool on can turn it off with a single motion. A switch that sticks in the on position, or a lock-on button that will not release, keeps the tool running after you let go.
Under Mississippi’s product liability statute, you must prove, more likely than not, that the tool was a defective product when it left the company’s control, that the defect made it unreasonably dangerous, and that the defect caused your injury. A failed kill switch can fit any of the statute’s four defect types:
- A manufacturing defect, where your switch did not match the maker’s specifications
- A design defect, where every tool of that model carries the same flawed switch
- A failure to warn, where the warnings or instructions did not adequately cover a danger the maker knew or should have known about and an ordinary user would not recognize
- A broken express warranty, where the maker made a promise about the tool that was untrue and you relied on it
In each case, the result can be the same: a blade or bit that keeps moving after you let go of the trigger, which can cause deep cuts, broken bones, or amputations. A single bad switch suggests a mistake at the factory. A switch that fails the same way across a product line suggests a design problem.
A design claim also requires proof that the manufacturer knew, or should have known, about the danger, that the tool failed to function as expected, and that a feasible design alternative existed. A feasible design alternative is a safer design that would probably have prevented your injury without making the tool less useful. An engineer looks for one by comparing the failed switch with designs available when the tool left the factory.
Mississippi law also limits warning claims. The maker owes no warning about a danger that is known or open and obvious to ordinary users. Everyone knows a spinning blade can cut. No one can see a switch wearing out inside the handle.
What Evidence Is Important in a Product Liability Claim?
The tool is the key evidence. An engineer can open the switch housing and see whether a spring broke, the contacts fused, or someone rewired the trigger. Keep these items:
- The tool, unrepaired, with its battery, blade, cord, and attachments
- Photos of the tool, the work area, and your injuries
- The receipt, manual, box, and warning labels
- Repair and maintenance records, the incident report, and witness names and statements
- Any recall or safety notice for the tool, which you can check in the federal recall database
Do not return the tool to the store or mail it to the manufacturer. If you were hurt at work, ask your employer in writing to preserve it. Do not take the tool apart or try to fix it yourself. Let an engineer examine it first. Most Mississippi personal injury lawsuits must be filed within three years after the claim arises.
Can You Recover Compensation Beyond Workers’ Compensation?
If you were hurt at work and your employer is covered by Mississippi’s workers’ compensation law, workers’ compensation usually replaces your right to sue your employer for damages. Most private employers with five or more employees must carry this coverage. The statute makes one exception: if your employer failed to carry the required coverage, you can choose between claiming benefits and suing the employer. Courts also allow a lawsuit in the rare case where an employer acted with an actual intent to injure a worker. Carelessness, even serious carelessness, is not enough.
Workers’ compensation does not block a claim against the manufacturer. Taking benefits does not affect your right to sue other responsible parties, such as the manufacturer, a seller, or a repair shop. Three rules apply to that lawsuit:
- You must notify your employer or its insurer within 15 days of filing suit, and either one can join the case
- From any recovery, the reasonable costs of collection come out first, the next share repays the employer or insurer for benefits it paid and counts toward benefits it would otherwise still owe you, and anything left over belongs to you
- A settlement needs approval from the court, or from the Mississippi Workers’ Compensation Commission if no lawsuit has been filed
Mississippi law also lets the jury assign a share of the blame to your employer, even though you cannot sue the employer. Each company you can sue generally pays only its own share, so blame placed on your employer can reduce what you recover. Because the insurer is repaid from the recovery, your lawyer should plan the product case and the compensation claim together.
Your workers’ compensation claim has its own deadlines. Tell your employer about the injury within 30 days. If no benefits have been paid, a claim generally must be filed within two years.
If You Kept Using a Tool You Knew Was Faulty
The manufacturer’s lawyers can ask whether you noticed the switch acting up before the injury. Mississippi law gives the maker a complete defense if you knew about the condition, understood the danger, and deliberately chose to keep using the tool. The defense requires all three. If you were partly at fault, you can still recover, but the jury reduces your award by your share of the blame.
How Chatham Gilder Howell Pittman Can Help
Our firm’s roots in North Mississippi go back to 1932, and when you call us, you talk directly with an attorney. Our personal injury attorneys investigate how the tool failed. We secure the tool and other critical evidence, work with engineers to find where the switch failed, and identify every company that made, sold, rented, or repaired it. We also handle catastrophic injury claims, including amputations. We pursue full compensation for your injuries, and when a manufacturer will not pay a fair amount, our trial attorneys are prepared to go to court.
Talk With a North Mississippi Product Liability Attorney
If a power tool kept running when it should have stopped, let’s talk about it. For a free and confidential consultation, contact us to speak with a lawyer today. We charge no attorney fees unless we recover compensation for you. We serve North Mississippi from our offices in Southaven and Hernando.
